Mexican fish balls, albondigas de pescado, are a thing all over that country, and versions exist pretty much in every state with a coastline… which is most of them.
These I made from Pacific rockfish (but any fish will do), and are served in a light tomato broth. Great for hot summer suppers, or as an appetizer for a larger seafood feast.
Fish balls, as you might imagine, are meatballs made with fish. They are lighter and springier than red meat meatballs, and you see versions of them all over the world. Asia does a lot of fish balls, and I have a recipe for German fish meatballs, too.
I cobbled my recipe for fish balls together from about a dozen Spanish language cookbooks, plus a couple English language ones, but I leaned most heavily on a recipe in the book Cocina Familiar en el Estado de Baja Sur. It’s not an easy book to find, but there are copies here and there in the US.
Albondigas de pescado are one of the specialties of La Paz, the capital city of Baja Sur, and a place Holly and I love to visit. They are mostly either fried or simmered in a caldo, a light broth. Once you make your fish balls, you can go either route with this recipe.
As you can see in the pictures, these are finely textured fish balls, which is how I like them. They are not fish cakes, and they are made with raw fish that is then cooked, so you get a prettier fish ball that isn’t lumpy — and, more importantly, holds together. I tried making them with flaked, leftover fish and they fell apart.
A word on what fish to make fish balls from. There is no real rule, but in general you want “normal” fish, which is to say your typical white, flaky fish — freshwater or salt. Really firm, steaky fish like tuna or sturgeon aren’t great choices, nor are really oily fish like mackerel or jacks, although mackerel is used a lot for Asian fish balls. I do really like salmon and trout for fish balls.
I cook these by dusting them in flour or masa harina and dropping them into simmering salted water. When they float, give them another minute or so, then move to the sauce. Could you cook them in the broth itself? Sure, but you’d need broth more than you’d use and it would muddy the flavor of the broth.
Your other option is to fry them after dusting in flour or the masa harina. I only do this if I am deep frying because if you shallow fry any sort of meatball, you get this odd ring in the center where it was fried twice — you flip the meatballs, remember — and they tend to get misshapen when you shallow fry.
If you decide to fry your fish balls, drop them into 350°F oil until they are golden brown, roughly 5 minutes.
The poached balls I serve these with a light tomato/chile broth, but you can simply go with any sauce of your choice if you’ve decided to fry them. Garlicky aioli is always a good call, or you can mimic my recipe for salt cod fritters and do a saffron aioli, which is both delicious and pretty.
Once cooked, you can keep fish balls in the fridge for a few days in a covered container, and they can be frozen.
Mexican Fish Balls
Ingredients
FISH BALLS
- 1 tablespoon lard or olive oil
- 1 small white onion, minced
- 1 Anaheim or poblano chile, roasted, peeled, seeded and chopped
- 2 cloves garlic, minced
- 1 teaspoon Salt
- 1 pound skinless, boneless fish, roughly chopped
- 1 cup breadcrumbs
- 1 egg, lightly beaten
- 2 tablespoons minced cilantro or mint
- Flour or masa harina for dusting
BROTH
- 1 white onion, peeled and quartered
- 4 plum tomatoes, halved
- 3 to 4 Anaheim or poblano chiles
- 2 teaspoons Mexican oregano (regular oregano is fine)
- 3 tablespoons olive oil or lard
- 1 quart fish stock, shrimp stock or chicken stock
- Salt
Instructions
BROTH
- Get a comal, griddle, cast iron pan or other heavy pan hot. Set the quartered onion, halved tomatoes and chiles on it. Char the cut sides of the tomatoes black, and all sides of the onion and chiles. Set the chiles in a plastic bag after the skins are burnt. This will help you steam the skins off. Wait 15 to 30 minutes and then peel, deseed and remove the stems of the chiles.
- Put everything in a blender and puree.
- Heat the lard or oil in a saucepot, then pour in the contents of the blender. It will sputter and spit, so you might want to cover the pot. Stir constantly until the fat or oil has incorporated into the sauce, then slowly pour in the stock,. stirring constantly. Add salt to taste, cover the pot and turn it to low.
FISH BALLS
- Get a large pot of water to the simmering point, then add enough salt so it tastes salty.
- Meanwhile, heat the lard or olive oil in a small pan and sauté the onion, chile and garlic until soft but not browned, about 5 minutes. Turn off the heat and let cool.
- When the vegetables have cooled, put them into a food processor along with the remaining fish ball ingredients except the flour. Pulse to combine, or run the processor until you get a paste. Your choice. I like them finely chopped so I run the processor for a minute or so.
- Form balls from the mixture about the size of a walnut or smaller. Roll in flour or masa harina and gently drop them into the simmering water. Simmer until they float, then for about 1 to 2 minutes more. When they are done, move the fish balls to the broth.
- Serve the fish balls with the broth and some chopped cilantro.
Notes
Keys to Success
- Slightly wetting your hands with water makes it easier to form perfect fish balls.
- The flour or masa coating on the balls will set in the hot water, making prettier balls. Same deal if you fry them.
- Any green herb can be used in place of the cilantro or mint in the balls. Pipicha, parsley, savory, pitiona, epazote, etc.
- Yes, gluten free breadcrumbs will work here.
- You can make the broth richer and darker by using dried ancho or guajillo chiles instead of green Anaheims. Just rehydrate them with hot water and remove the stems and seeds.
- Unless you have really nice fish stock or seafood stock, use chicken stock.
This recipe absolutely exceeded my expectations, really delicious with an amazing texture and flavor profile.
We made it with the fillet off a jack we caught off the pacific coast of Mexico.
*Pro tip – instead of breadcrumbs use crushed up saltine crackers.
Do you use cooked or raw fish?
Kelly: Raw fish.
Absolutely fantastic! I had never heard of “fish balls” so had to give it a go. Living in Indiana I used walleye caught up on Lake Erie. Marvelous. I am looking forward to using the bluegill & small bass from my backyard pond.
I would suggest making the broth a day ahead & refrigerating over night. The leftover broth next day was 3 times a good. Had eaten all the balls so popped some shrimp in it. WOW! Thanks for the novel approach to fish.
I Iove this recipe! We make elk birria and trout cakes just about weekly, so this felt like a beautiful light subtle combination of both of those.
Always appreciate your creative and intriguing recipes.
Made it tonight and it was excellent. My cilantro had gone to seed, so I used mint, and it had a nice tang (although I think that cilantro would have been better). Did the onions, tomatoes and peppers (I used poblanos) under the broiler, worked fine. It did require a fair amount of salt in the broth. I think next time I will try to cook the albondigas in the broth for added flavor. ?
These would be amazing with northern pike… I’m guessing on that but we have a ton of those around northwest MN and any new recipe is a blessing. I bet fresh wild bergamot or anise hyssop would be a great addition as local wild ingredient.
I made this tonight and they are excellent!!!
Wow, so much effort for so little flavor. I was excited to make this dish, I am happy to put lots of effort into cooking. But, even my happy with everything I make husband was unimpressed. I added spices, I dosed it with my chili mix, more cumin, lime, ground black pepper, it was then ok, little ok, and I still love the idea, but next time it will be all me all seasoning. BTW, peppers are better over a flame than on a comal. After that, thanks for the basic idea.
Michele: Yes I am aware that peppers are better over a flame but I would not require someone to start a fire to make this dish. And you should know that not all Mexican dishes are knock you over the head. They do subtle, too. Sorry you did not like this recipe.
I have to try this!
This is too exciting. Ijust bought rockfish. Didn’t know what to do with it.