Oyster! Oyster! Oyster!

5 from 3 votes
Jump to Recipe

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

oyster mushroom, oyster plant, pickled oyster recipe, served in a bowl
Photo by Holly A. Heyser

Every now and again I am struck in the forehead with the idea for a dish; this one came to me while stuck in traffic on Highway 50, two years ago. I dubbed the dish “Oyster, Oyster, Oyster,” and immediately set about making it. It’s taken me forever to perfect it, but finally I have something I would be proud to serve anyone.

The genesis of “Oyster, Oyster, Oyster” comes from my habit of growing odd vegetables, things many of my fellow gardeners have either considered useless or have never even heard about. It’s like the old saying about the produce aisle, where you’re supposed to buy one thing each week you’ve never eaten before — only my produce aisle is, for the most part, either the natural world around me, or my garden.

That’s how I came to plant scorzonera. Never heard of scorzonera? It’s like salsify, only with black skin. Still not helpful? How about its other name, oyster plant? Still nothing? No worries, it’s not the most popular plant in the produce section.

That is a shame. Having now eaten it, I can say the world is less of a place because we eat so little oyster plant — and that oyster plant is less of a vegetable, at least in most people’s eyes, because of the dolt who named it such. Whoever he was ought to be punched dead in the face.

Think on it. “Hey Holly, want some oyster plant?” What would you say? That I want to eat a plant that tastes like an oyster? Or worse, eat a plant with the consistency of an oyster? Fer chrissakes, who the hell in his right mind would ever want to put something like that in his mouth?

I can fix it: I now christen this skinny, homely root “Artichoke Heart Plant.” There. It’s done. I have waved my magic wand, drawn the pentagram, given alms to the saints and sacrificed the goat. Why the new name? Because scorzonera, salsify or whatever, really tastes far more like an artichoke heart than anything else I have ever eaten. Other than artichoke hearts, that is.

If you like artichoke hearts, seek out salsify. Or scorzonera. Or oyster plant. And when you find or grow some, there are any number of things to do with it. I decided to boil the roots with a few potatoes, mash them with butter, milk and thyme, then roll the mash in egg and panko breadcrumbs and call it a croquette.

Salsify croquettes rock. I could have eaten three of them. Light, creamy, and full of salsify goodness. Or is that Artichoke Heart Plant goodness? You decide. My original dish also had oyster mushrooms and a weird greenish sauce made from pureed oysters. Thus, “Oyster, Oyster, Oyster.” It tasted good, but it was ugly. Really ugly.

First rendition of the salsify, oyster and oyster mushroom recipe
Photo by Hank Shaw

This presentation just didn’t do justice to the concept of the dish I had in my head. It was close, but needed a lot of work.

One of my problems with the initial dish was the actual oysters: They were huge, too big to place on top of the croquette. And I tried to pickle them, but that made things worse. They tasted like giant, acidic globs of snot. That’s why I buzzed them in a blender. The surprise was that they actually tasted good as a sauce.


finished oyster mushrooms, salsify croquette, poached oyster recipe
Photo by Holly A. Heyser

So, for the redux I decided to make everything smaller. Smaller croquette, smaller oyster mushrooms, smaller oyster. If you don’t like the idea, blame Thomas Keller, whose philosophy that a dish ought to only have a couple of bites  — any more and your palate gets fatigued — has taken a hold of me in recent years.

The seared oyster mushrooms serve as a bed for the oyster shell that holds everything else; without a bed of some sort, the shell will teeter on the plate. I then gently poached a small oyster in butter to top the croquette. A single borage flower adds some needed color and, if you concentrate while eating it, you will pick up its cucumber-like flavor.

I think it’s one of the most beautiful dishes I’ve ever come up with, and, so far as I know, it is original — a rare thing these days.

oyster mushroom, oyster plant, pickled oyster recipe
5 from 3 votes

Oyster, Oyster, Oyster

As fancy as this dish looks, really the hardest part of it is finding the salsify: You can find it in specialty groceries in fall through spring. Scorzonera is a black-skinned variety. You can also buy salsify seeds and grow your own. There is no real substitute if you want to really have the three "oysters" in the dish, but a mashed potato croquette will look and taste fine. Use small oysters and small oyster mushrooms here, if you can. This is supposed to be an appetizer, or one course in a many-coursed meal.
Course: Appetizer
Cuisine: American
Servings: 4 people
Author: Hank Shaw
Prep Time: 20 minutes
Cook Time: 20 minutes
Total Time: 40 minutes


  • 1 pound salsify or scorzonera root
  • A lemon
  • 1/2 pound white potatoes (they must be white)
  • Salt
  • 1/2 cup unsalted butter, divided
  • 1/4 cup whole milk or cream
  • 1/2 teaspoon thyme leaves
  • 2 eggs, beaten
  • 2 cups panko breadcrumbs
  • Oil for frying (Canola, peanut or vegetable)
  • 1 pound oyster mushrooms
  • 4 oysters in their shells
  • 4 borage flowers, or other small, edible flower


  • Scrub the oyster shells well with a brush to remove all grit and dirt. Squeeze the lemon into a large bowl of cold water, and bring a pot of salted water to a boil. Peel the salsify (oyster plant, scorzon…you know what I mean…) one at a time and put each root into the water. When you’re done, cut each root into short discs and put into the boiling water.
  • Peel the potatoes, cut into pieces roughly the same size as the oyster plant and add them to the boiling water — this method ensures that both are soft at about the same time. Boil both veggies for 30 minutes or so; the salsify will take longer to soften than the potatoes.
  • Meanwhile, shuck the oysters over a bowl, letting the juice fall into the bowl. Set the oysters in a small bowl in the fridge. Strain the oyster juice through a paper towel into a small pot. Add 5 tablespoons of butter to the pot and melt over low heat.
  • When the salsify and potatoes are ready, mash with 1 tablespoon butter, thyme and a little of the milk or cream: You want the mash to be pretty solid, not super smooth or wet. Form the mashed salsify and potatoes into small discs. Dip into the beaten egg and then into the panko bread crumbs (you really do want panko breadcrumbs, which are very coarse; it’s a texture thing.) and be gentle, as this is not a very solid mass.
  • Get enough oil to reach up about 1/2 of an inch up the sides of a frying pan, and begin heating it to 350 degrees. You'll know the oil is hot enough when a pinch of flour sizzles immediately. Slide the croquettes gently into the hot oil. Fry until golden brown, about 2 minutes, then flip and cook the other side. When they’re all a lovely golden brown, drain the croquettes on a rack.
  • Heat another saute pan over high heat for 1 minute, then add the oyster mushrooms. Shake the pan constantly so the mushrooms don't stick until they sizzle and begin to release their water. Sprinkle salt over the mushrooms. When most of the water is gone, add the remaining butter and saute until the mushrooms begin to brown. When they are nicely browned, turn off the heat.
  • Turn the heat back onto the melted butter-oyster juice pot. When it begins to sizzle, turn off the heat and slip in the oysters. Remove after 1-2 minutes, or when the edges curl. Salt them lightly. To serve, place some oyster mushrooms down on the plate, then top with the clean bottom part of the oyster shell. Put the croquette in the shell, then top with the poached oyster and finally with a single borage flower.

Nutrition information is automatically calculated, so should only be used as an approximation.

Tried this recipe? Tag me today!Mention @huntgathercook or tag #hankshaw!


You May Also Like

Smoked Salmon Deviled Eggs

Deviled eggs are one of those foods I have a hard time controlling myself with. These deviled eggs, made with smoked salmon, are especially good.

Chinese Scallion Pancakes

Chinese style scallion pancakes — really flatbreads — are super easy to make and are a dangerously addicting snack.

Potted Shrimp

A recipe for British potted shrimp, made with tiny pink cocktail shrimp, which are one of the most sustainable shrimp you can buy. Easy and tasty!

Wild Rice Salad

A fresh and bright wild rice salad recipe that mimics Crisp and Green’s “wild child” salad. I use grouse, wild rice and dried wild berries.

About Hank Shaw

Hey there. Welcome to Hunter Angler Gardener Cook, the internet’s largest source of recipes and know-how for wild foods. I am a chef, author, and yes, hunter, angler, gardener, forager and cook. Follow me on Instagram and on Facebook.

5 from 3 votes (3 ratings without comment)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating


  1. Neat concept w/the three oysters. I didn’t realize salsify has such a flavor, both of which I like. I hope to find it (out in nature or in a grocery store) some day.

  2. Very nice. I have wanted to try oyster plant for some time. I love oysters, and artichokes too for that matter. And now I have a great recipe to try. Thanks!

    And totally off the point. I am an avid fly fisher and reader. Its stands to reason that one author I really enjoy is John Gierach; an excellent fishing writer. His most recent book, “No Shortage of Good Days” has an great chapter about book signing tours. Having read some of your tour experiences, I think you might enjoy it,

  3. having never had the oyster plant, I am nonetheless sure that I would love this. Fried goodness, mushrooms and oysters? Count me in!
    Did you consider calling it “Oyster cubed”? (I don’t know how to do the little “3” in comments, but you get the idea.)

  4. I have not had oysters in years and it is apparent from this post that I must change that. Looks wonderful Hank!

  5. Hi Hank! Great post as always and a very creative dish! From one chef to another…If you want the diner to taste all the components together, I would suggest serving the oyster shell on a bed of rock salt and spices and put the oyster mushrooms between the oyster and the croquette. Another idea would be to make a sauce from the oyster mushroom to place in the bottom of the oyster shell before placing the croquette and poached oyster on top. Love your posts!

  6. Wow, that’s beautiful. I’ve never heard of an oyster plant before so that’s great too!

  7. I’ve seen it called “black salsify,” and it’s grown by Tierra Vegetables in Sonoma County. They bring some to the Ferry Plaza Farmer’s Market every Saturday morning all through late fall and winter. It’s delicious and I’ve used it in a number of dishes.